Banlist Update > Throne of Eldraine < 2019

 

So, what do you think about Throne of Eldraine ? We love the Artwork and the flavour of Fairy Tales and Knights is fresh yet feels familiar.  The food token mechanism seems rather weak, though, and we think none of the Throne of Eldraine cards has a high impact on Team Commander (At least in our playtests we didn’t see any immanent danger). But some other, older cards were creating a lot of worries recently, so here is an update to the Ban List:

We are still happy and satisfied with the format itself: it is versatile, stable and many different Commanders and Playstyles are viable. We do see that Aggro-Decks are quite strong and playable, but we also have late-game (infinite)combos and 7+ cc cards which can end games, too.

The following cards are unbanned as Commander:


While Zur the Enchanter is still a strong and very oppressive commander, we think that his glory days are gone, and with new commanders claiming the board Zur will loose some of his supremacy status. Let’s see how he works out unbanned – will he once again be unbeatable ?

The most cards which are newly banned like Skull Storm are abusing the 2HG / Team Commander format (the fact that you have 2 enemies): these cards are too powerful in the format, so a Skull Storm can deal 2x half the life of a team = instant death if no creatures can be sacrificed. Same goes for Loyal Subordinate and Gonti’s Machinations  which deal too much damage in 2HG for thir mana cost, and especially Chandra, Awakened Inferno’s Emblems, which are sheer unremovable and unevitable. Raiders‘ Wake is in the same line like Megrim – with Wheel of Fortune they are insane n 2HG. As we allow theese Wheel-Effects (as red has already few card draws), the Megrim-Effects and the Alms Collector / Leovold combos therefore need bannings.

We still try to ban as few cards as possible (though you may not believe it when you see our list)… we don’t ban all combo cards ! Yes, some players still do not agree with our philosophy and ask us to ban more combocards, but we are fine with them right now: as long as a combo isn’t archieved too easily and too early in a game, but instead is a late-game-win or needs several cards, we are okay with that. Also, it’s sheer impossible to ban all cards which have a combo potential.

We also can’t ban all card combinations which could possibly lead to a mask discard situation – we are fine that discard can be a viable option, but discard as a mechanism is limited due too high mana costs and the cards itself so that it neither happens too early in a game and seldom that the complete hand of an opponent can be discarded (regularly). Sadistic Hypnotist can be one possibility to do so, so we banned it before it gets abused too often.

The last banned card needs a bit of explanation, as it might not be too obvious: Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth might seem strange, but it has a great impact: it slows down Cabal Coffers a bit. There are other coffer-like cards, and we don’t want to remove this quite fast mana option from Team Commander, but by banning Urborg, the amount of Mana you get is reduced a bit, the speed of getting fast mana is reduced, and the speed and availability is removed: now coffers is more likely to be played in mono black, and the coffers are slower, as you can’t splice them into other colored Decks easily, and therefore can’t benefit from immense ramp of green.

We have an eye on 3 Commanders right now, but we are not sure yet. Also some too easy combo cards may get banned soon. We do watch the lists of Free-for-all Commander and Duelcommander closely, too, and value thier experience and opinions (we really do – though we favour Teamplay, and bloat that our format is better and more joyful, we do have a very high opinion of the guys !) — but some commanders/cards are not that effective in our format like Zurgo Bellringer or Arahbo (not saying that these cards are bad or unplayable at all, but their impact is higher in a duelcommander environment). The other way round is Edric, which is unbanned in duelcommander, but is much more worse in Team Commander, so we don’t unban it.
We haven’t banned Timetwister. We see the strong point of monetory and availability, but we have a hard time to draw a line here: how much is too much or too costy ? Should a card be banned if it costs 100€ or more like duallands ? Or 50 € ? Or 10 € ? For kitchen table and friends groups you could use proxys to try the card…. for tournament and official games please always use original cards, and then, if you think this card makes the decisive point, buy it.
 

Have Fun and Good Games ! – The Teamcommander-Team